Widening tax gap casts doubt over MTD

The amount of tax lost in the UK through non-payment, avoidance and fraud increased to 5.3% (£35 billion) in 2019/20, official statistics show.

HMRC secured 94.7% of all tax due in 2019/20 but saw its ‘tax gap' widen, despite the introduction of Making Tax Digital (MTD) for VAT.

Income tax, National Insurance contributions and capital gains tax made up the largest share of uncollected taxes (36%), closely followed by lost VAT (35%).

MTD for VAT kicked in for most of the UK's VAT-registered businesses from 1 April 2019, and will apply to all VAT-registered firms from 1 April 2022.

HMRC said the compulsory digital accounting methods for certain VAT-registered businesses would simplify the tax system and help close the tax gap.

In total, 8.4% of all VAT payments went uncollected, prompting economist and MTD critic Richard Murphy, of Tax Research UK, to state "MTD for VAT had failed".

The Chartered Institute of Taxation (CIOT) said "there's no sign" that MTD for VAT has so far reduced the amount of tax lost to "avoidable errors".

John Barnett, chair of technical policy and oversight committee at CIOT, added, however, the tax gap figures "suggest HMRC is still collecting about 95% of tax due, which compares well internationally".

The UK's overall tax gap rose 0.3% in 2019/20, up from 5% in 2018/19 - the first increase since 2013/14 when the gap was 7.1%.

Talk to us about Making Tax Digital.

You’re in good

hands

We’re great at bringing a range of services to those who need them most. If you pick up a phone and give us a call, we’ll be more than ready to talk to you about our services and all that we offer. We’ve been helping businesses and individuals see real value in what they do for years now.

Business services

Offering a comprehensive range of accounting services to encourage growth.

Read more

Personal finance

Looking after your own money is tricky. That’s where we can really help you out.

Read more

Cloud accounting

Keeping all your financial information in one place is a great time-saver.

Read more

Seen enough? Give us a call

Quickbooks logo
BBF member badge